0
Votes

‘The Chokepoint’: Plaza 500 Electric Substation Faces Mandated Fairfax Public Hearing

Section 2232 Review, Planning Commission Meeting Planned for Dec. 2

Two sides are at odds over the Plaza 500 Electric Substation — officially Dominion Energy’s Edsall Substation, Fairfax County application 2232-2025-MA-00007 — ahead of a scheduled Dec. 2 Fairfax County Planning Commission vote. The Section 2232 application covers the 5-acre Dominion Energy high-voltage electrical substation required to power Starwood Capital Group’s proposed Plaza 500 data center campus. The two-building, 461,444-square-foot project spans 34 acres at 6295 and 6299 Edsall Road in Lincolnia in the Mason District, along the City of Alexandria border.

With pre-construction work looming and other regulatory doors closed, opponents in Bren Mar Park and Lincolnia Park are drawing what could be their final card at the Dec. 2 hearing, hoping to persuade the Planning Commission to halt the project by denying its power infrastructure.

Starwood Capital Group — operating through Starwood Digital Ventures as Plaza 500 LLC — is developing the two-building complex. Because the facility is a "by-right" industrial project, county planners have accepted site plan submittals, the Virginia State Corporation Commission cleared transmission line routing on Aug. 8, 2025, and the Fairfax County Board of Supervisors has no direct land-use veto over the buildings themselves.

The Connection sent five requests for comment before publication and received responses from Starwood Digital Ventures, Mason District Supervisor Andres Jimenez, and Save Bren Mar. Dominion Energy and Fairfax County planning staff did not respond before the deadline late last week.


Developer and Official Responses

On Friday, Nov. 13, a Starwood Digital Ventures spokesperson wrote in an email: "SDV has been investing in Fairfax County since 2019. We remain committed to this project and to our neighbors here in the community. The planned redevelopment of the Plaza 500 site is an essential opportunity for Fairfax County to deliver a less obtrusive investment that enables its growth, providing high-quality jobs and needed tax revenue and supporting funding for education, first responders and other essential community services. SDV is continuing to work closely with Dominion Energy and Fairfax County to ensure plans for the Edsall Road substation, a public good subsidized by SDV, are community-conscious and low-impact."

While Dominion Energy did not respond before publication, the utility states on its Edsall Substation webpage that the facility is needed "to meet the area's growing electrical needs" and "will support new data center development while helping provide reliable electric service for local homes, businesses and communities."

County planning staff is expected to release its formal Section 2232 report and recommendation ahead of the Dec. 2 hearing.

Meanwhile, Jimenez restated his opposition in a Friday statement. While acknowledging the need for reliable power, he said protecting neighborhoods is his priority. "I do not believe Dominion Energy’s Edsall Road Substation proposal, as currently presented, fully explores alternative site locations or design options." He noted concerns over visual impacts, proximity to homes and neighborhood compatibility, adding he would vote against the application if appealed to the Board of Supervisors.

Jimenez’s office added that it worked with the Lincolnia Park Recreational Club and Lincolnia Park Civic Association following Dominion’s July notice regarding possible investigations on club property, noting the issue is resolved.


Opposition Concerns

Opponents say the proposal conflicts with neighborhood protections in the county comprehensive plan.

"We strongly believe that the County Comprehensive Plan, the basis of the 2232 review, does not support approval of the massive 5-acre data center substation at this location," Tyler Ray of Save Bren Mar wrote in an email. "It is inconsistent with both the Lincolnia Planning District site-specific plan that calls for 'preserving stable residential areas' and that 'infill development must match the character, intensity, and density of existing residential uses,' and the broader County Comprehensive Plan goals relating to land use, economic development, and public facilities."

Ray said approving the facility near homes would set a countywide precedent, comparing what opponents say is a 67-foot setback to prior county approvals.

"If the county staff, Planning Commission, or the Board of Supervisors finds that a substation of this size and scope (can power 40,000-120,000 homes) is appropriate a mere 67 feet from a residential district, they will have to approve all other future data center[s] and other substations that are also in such close proximity," Ray wrote, noting the last four similar county-approved substations sit 900 feet to 5,500 feet from residential districts.

Ray also addressed Dominion’s outreach, citing "vaguely worded letters" to the Lincolnia pool and edits to its project webpage, saying residents and officials "simply cannot trust what Dominion is saying." Save Bren Mar also opposes downsizing the substation.

“The proposed Plaza 500 data center is wrong for our community,” said Paul Gilbert, a conservationist and former executive director of NOVA Parks who lives in Springfield, in a statement to The Connection. “The way this can be rejected is for the Planning Commission to turn down the power substation. Without lots of power, there is no data center.”

Gilbert said that if the Fairfax County Planning Commission “does the right thing and rejects the power substation,” the data center company can still “appeal the decision to the Board of Supervisors.” He added that the board “usually” does not reverse the Planning Commission.

“We should not approve any new data centers until the carbon pollution, water usage and noise issues have been resolved,” Gilbert added. “Let’s think globally and act locally.”